May 5, 2023

What Is the Best Telematics Solution? How to Choose One and Build the Business Case

There is no single best telematics solution. How to judge one for your fleet and build the business case: costs, savings and a worked 30-van example.

What Is the Best Telematics Solution? How to Choose One and Build the Business Case
In this article

There is no single best telematics solution, in the world or in any one country. The best one for your business reads the data you need from the vehicles you actually run, feeds the software your team already works in, and pays for itself on your own numbers. Below is how to judge a system in that order and how to build the business case for it: the costs to count, the savings to estimate and a worked example for a fleet of 30 vans.

One caveat before we start. We make fleet software, so we are a supplier too. This page ranks no products, and the checks in it work on any supplier, us included.

Why nobody can name one best system

A telematics solution is four things bought together: a device in the vehicle, a SIM card with a data plan, software that shows the data, and the people who install and support it all. A system can be strong on one part and weak on another, and which weakness hurts depends on the fleet.

A courier company with 200 motorbikes needs a small unit that survives rain and vibration. A car sharing operator needs the device to lock and open the doors, which a tracking-only unit may not do. A contractor with excavators counts engine hours instead of kilometres. Put those fleets into one “top 10” and the ranking tells none of them anything. When you do read such a list, look at who published it and whether they sell one of the ten.

What you can do is narrow the field by type.

TypeWhat it doesFits when
Vehicle trackingLocation, trips, mileage and speed on a mapEach vehicle has one permanent driver and you mainly need to know where it is
Fleet management with telematicsTracking plus drivers, bookings, maintenance tasks and cost reports in one systemVehicles are shared, rented out or expensive to keep idle
Asset trackingBattery-powered tags on trailers, containers and machinery that report position at intervalsThe asset has no ignition or rarely moves
Video telematicsCameras that record the road and flag eventsAccident disputes and driver coaching are your main cost
Insurance telematicsDriving data goes to an insurer, which prices the policy on itYour insurer offers it and puts the terms in writing
Factory-fitted telematicsData from the modem the manufacturer built in, with no extra deviceThe fleet is recent, of one or two makes, and the data can be exported to your software

The words get mixed up, so briefly. GPS tracking is location only. Telematics is location plus the state of the vehicle (ignition, mileage, fuel or battery level) and, with some devices, commands sent back to it. Telemetry is the wider engineering term for any remote measurement, on vehicles or anything else.

How to judge a telematics solution for your fleet

Go through the questions in this order. The first three can rule a system out before price comes up.

  1. What data do you need? Write down the decisions you want to make (which driver needs a talk, when a van is due for service, whether you can do without two cars) and the signals behind them: location, ignition, odometer, fuel or battery level, harsh braking. Anything outside that list is a feature you’d pay for and never open.
  2. Does it read that data on your vehicles? Ask the supplier to confirm it by model and year. Ask about fuel level and door locks by name, because not every device reads the first or controls the second.
  3. Do you need to send commands? Locking and opening the doors or blocking the engine remotely decides the class of device, so say it at the start.
  4. How is it installed? A hardwired unit is hidden and hard to remove. A plug-in unit goes in within minutes and comes out just as fast, in anyone’s hands. Ask who does the installation, where, and how long each vehicle is off the road.
  5. What happens without signal? Data travels over the mobile network. In underground car parks and remote areas it can arrive late or go missing, so ask whether the unit stores trips and sends them later, and what roaming costs if your vehicles cross borders.
  6. Where does the data go? It should reach the fleet, rental or dispatch software you already use, through an API or at least an export. Ask who owns the history and whether you can take it with you when the contract ends.
  7. What does the contract say? Term, notice period, who owns the devices, the fee when the fleet shrinks, the cost of taking units out.
  8. Have the drivers been told? Put in writing what is recorded and when, and check the privacy and employment rules where you operate before the first unit goes in.

Is it reliable? Run a pilot

Every supplier says the system is reliable, and a pilot is the only way to know. Take five vehicles for four to six weeks and include the awkward ones: the oldest van, the one that sleeps in an underground car park, the one that crosses a border. Each week count the trips the system missed or cut short, the hours a unit was offline and the positions that were plainly wrong. Compare the odometer on the dashboard with the mileage in the software on the first and the last day. Agree with the supplier beforehand which numbers count as a pass.

Options for a small fleet

With five to fifteen vehicles there are four ways to get the data.

OptionSet-upWhat you getWatch for
Plug-in tracker with a phone appYou fit it yourselfLive location and a list of tripsEasy to unplug; little vehicle data
Hardwired unit with fleet softwareAn installer visits each vehicleTrips, mileage, alerts, driving behaviour, with some devices door controlContract length and the cost of removal
Factory-fitted data from the manufacturerActivation, no hardwareLocation and odometer; the rest depends on the makeA mixed fleet ends up with a portal per make
Tracking through the driver’s phoneAn app on each phoneTrips while the app is runningIt follows the phone, so it stops when the phone is off or left behind

If every vehicle has one permanent driver, the first or the third row may be all you need. Once vehicles are shared between people, look at the second.

Building the business case

A business case for telematics fits on one page: what it costs, what it saves, how soon the second covers the first, and what would make the answer wrong. Finance will ask about that last part, so write it yourself. A strong business case has a baseline behind every saving, measured before anything is installed, and a named person who has to deliver it.

Costs to count

  • Devices and installation per vehicle, including the hours each vehicle is off the road.
  • Subscription and SIM data per vehicle per month, for the whole contract term.
  • Set-up: connecting it to your other software, loading vehicles and drivers, training.
  • Somebody’s hour a week to read the reports. Without that hour none of the savings below happen.
  • The exit: removing units, early-termination fees, replacing devices that fail outside warranty.

Savings to estimate

Keep two columns, money that stops leaving the bank account and staff time that is freed. An hour saved turns into cash only if it was overtime or gets filled with other paid work, and whoever signs the budget knows it.

  • Fuel: idling, speeding, trips outside working hours. You need a baseline in litres per 100 km for the last three months.
  • Admin time: phone calls to find a vehicle, paper log books, working out who was driving when a fine arrives.
  • Vehicles: if trip data shows that two vans hardly leave the yard, the saving is two vans you don’t replace. Here is how to calculate fleet utilisation.
  • Maintenance: service by real mileage and fewer missed intervals.
  • Theft and misuse: a stolen vehicle found, private trips charged or stopped.
  • Insurance: count a discount only when the insurer has confirmed it in writing.

Three formulas are enough.

  • Net benefit per month = savings per month − running cost per month
  • Payback in months = one-off cost ÷ net benefit per month
  • Return over the contract = (net benefit per month × months − one-off cost) ÷ total cost over the contract

A worked example: 30 delivery vans in Dubai

The figures here are made up for illustration and aren’t anyone’s price list, ours included. Put your own quotes and bills in their place.

A food distributor runs 30 vans out of a warehouse in Al Quoz and delivers across Dubai and Sharjah. The fuel bill is AED 33,000 a month. The dispatcher spends about 17 hours a month phoning drivers to find vans and going through shift rosters when a fine arrives.

LineHow it is worked outAmount
Devices and installation, one-off30 × 450AED 13,500
Set-up and training, one-offEstimateAED 1,500
One-off costAED 15,000
Subscription and SIM data per month30 × 40AED 1,200
Fuel saving per month5% of 33,000AED 1,650
Dispatcher time per month17 hours × 40AED 680
Savings per monthFuel 1,650 + time 680AED 2,330
Net benefit per monthSavings 2,330 − subscription 1,200AED 1,130

Payback is 15,000 ÷ 1,130, a little over 13 months. Over a 36-month contract the net result is 1,130 × 36 − 15,000 = AED 25,680 on a total cost of AED 58,200, a return of 44%.

The weak spot is the 5%. Nobody knows that number before a pilot, so show what happens around it.

Fuel saving assumedNet benefit per monthPaybackNet over 36 months
3%AED 47032 monthsAED 1,920
5%AED 1,13013 monthsAED 25,680
8%AED 2,1207 monthsAED 61,320

At 3% the project only just pays for itself within the contract. At 8% it’s the easiest decision of the year.

So the case stands or falls on fuel, and the pilot described above has to measure fuel as well as reliability. For the five vans, work out litres per 100 km over the three months before from fuel receipts and odometer readings. Then run the pilot with someone reading the idling report every Monday and phoning the three drivers at the top of it. A tracker saves no fuel by sitting in a van. The Monday phone calls do.

Left out of the table on purpose: an insurance discount, fewer accidents, and the extra van this company hires for three months every year because nobody could show that the existing ones had room. Put them in the document as upside. A case that works without them is hard to argue with.

Telematics in CT Mobility

CT Mobility is software for car rental, car sharing and company fleets, and telematics is built into it. The platform is multi-hardware: devices from different suppliers work in one system, and we check compatibility for each vehicle model. Location and vehicle state arrive in the operator console as a live map, trip history, mileage and alerts. Where the device and the car support it, operators and verified users can lock and open the car or block the engine.

GPS fleet tracking is part of the core platform. Devices, installation and SIM cards are quoted separately, after we review your vehicle models. If you already have trackers, send us the device models and the number of vehicles, and we’ll tell you whether they can stay.

New to the subject as a whole? Start with what fleet management is and how it works.

‍

Launch your vehicle sharing app in just 15 days with CT Mobility!

No setup fees. Unlimited features.
Free trial period.