March 17, 2023

Car Sharing Benefits: What Users, Cities and Companies Gain

What car sharing saves a driver, what it changes for a city, how it differs from carpooling, and where it falls short.

Discovering the Practical Advantages of Car Sharing
In this article

Car sharing lets you use a car from a shared fleet only when you need it, for an hour, an afternoon or a day, and pay for that time or distance instead of owning the car. You book in an app, open the car with your phone or a member card, and the price typically covers fuel and insurance. The main benefit for a driver is simple: you stop paying every month for a car that stands parked most of the day.

Whether that adds up depends on how much you drive. Germany's Federal Environment Agency (UBA) gives a rule of thumb: if you drive less than 12,500 km a year, car sharing often pays off financially as well. For how booking, access and the end of a trip work step by step, see our guide to car sharing services.

Advantages for the people who use it

A car you own costs money whether it moves or not: insurance, tax, a parking space or permit, servicing, tyres, and the value it loses each year. Car sharing turns most of that into a price per trip. A quiet month costs little. A month without trips costs nothing, or a small membership fee if your provider charges one.

Take a household in a city that keeps a second car mostly for weekend shopping and visits to family: six trips a month, about three hours and 25 km each. The figures are illustrative, made up for the arithmetic.

Own second carCar sharing
Fixed costs per month (insurance, tax, parking, servicing, loss of value)€250€0
Fuel for 150 kmabout €16in the price
Time price, 6 trips × 3 h at €11 an hournone€198
Total for the monthabout €266€198

At six trips the shared car wins. Push it to twelve trips and sharing costs €396 while the own car rises only to about €282, because the fixed part does not change. In this example the two meet at roughly eight three-hour trips a month. Do the same sum with your own numbers; that one figure tells you more than any list of advantages.

The rest is about convenience. You can take a small car for town and a bigger one when you move furniture or drive to the airport with luggage, as long as the provider has one nearby. Repairs, tyre changes and inspection dates are the operator's job. In free-floating services you leave the car in any legal spot inside the operating area, so you don't need a parking space at home for it.

And what does it do to your own need for a car? France's ecological transition agency ADEME surveyed 2,768 car sharing users in 2022. Only 26.2% of them had a personal car, against 81.3% nationally. 69.5% had given up a car in their household, and for 40% of users this followed from using car sharing. The study also found that people change their habits when they sign up, and the new habits then stay stable.

What car sharing changes for a city

Most of the benefit for a city comes from one effect: people who join a car sharing service sell a car or never buy one. The most useful public figures come from France and Germany.

  • ADEME's 2022 national survey (carried out by the research firm 6t): one shared car replaces 5 to 8 private cars, removes 10,000 to 19,000 km of private car driving a year, and frees 0.9 to 3 on-street parking spaces.
  • Germany's UBA: each station-based shared car replaces four to more than ten cars, depending on local conditions, because users often give up their own car or second car. Shared fleets are usually renewed after three to four years, and these newer cars emit less CO2 per kilometre than the average private car in Germany.

Fewer parked cars is the part you can see. UBA points out that the freed space can go to other uses, such as green areas or playgrounds. Less driving is the part that counts for emissions and traffic.

Both agencies attach a condition. UBA calls the link with public transport a key precondition for the environmental benefit, and notes that users of station-based services in particular take buses, trains and bikes or walk more often, and so drive less. ADEME is blunt about scale as well: at national level the environmental impact of car sharing in France is not yet significant, because the services are small, and the survey estimates their volume would have to grow about a hundredfold for a real impact. The effect per shared car is well documented. The total depends on how many shared cars a city actually has.

Car sharing vs carpooling (and ride-hailing)

The words get mixed up because all of them involve sharing. In car sharing you share the car over time: you drive it, then someone else does. In carpooling you share a trip: one person drives their own car and takes passengers going the same way, who chip in for fuel and tolls.

Car sharingCarpoolingRide-hailing
Who drivesYouThe car ownerA paid driver
What is sharedThe car, one user after anotherSeats on one tripNothing, you order a ride
Whose carThe operator's fleet (or a private owner's in peer-to-peer sharing)The driver's ownThe driver's or the company's
How you payPer minute, hour, day or kmA share of the trip costsPer ride
FitsErrands, visits, trips where you need the car for a few hoursRegular commutes on the same route, long trips between citiesGetting from A to B without driving

Car sharing is also a form of rental, only shorter and self-service. How it differs from a traditional rental desk in price, paperwork and what is included is covered in car sharing vs car rental.

Downsides, and when your own car is still the better deal

  • The car isn't always there. Friday evening, a holiday weekend or a rainy morning can be exactly when everyone else wants one too.
  • If the nearest car is a 15-minute walk away, a ten-minute errand becomes a long one.
  • Per-minute prices punish traffic jams and long stops. For a day out, an hourly or daily package is usually cheaper.
  • Child seats, a roof box, the dog's blanket: you bring and fit them every time.
  • Insurance comes with an excess you pay after damage unless you buy a reduction, and some providers take a deposit.
  • You find the car the way the last driver left it. Check it and report damage or dirt in the app before you drive off.

If you drive to work every day, or live where shared cars are thin on the ground, owning or leasing a car usually still makes more sense. Car sharing works best next to decent buses, trains and bike lanes.

What to check before you sign up

Look at where the cars stand or how far the operating area reaches, both near home and near the places you go most. Read how pricing works: per minute, per hour, day packages, how many kilometres are included and what each extra one costs. Check the insurance excess, the deposit, and the fuel or charging rules (with an electric car, what battery level you must leave it at). When choosing a car for a trip, think about size and luggage and, for an electric car, whether its range covers the return leg.

Corporate car sharing: the advantages for a company

The same idea works inside a company. Instead of an assigned car for each employee, or keys in a drawer at reception, staff book cars from a shared pool in an app. For city-based staff who need a car a few times a week, a smaller shared pool can cover trips that would otherwise need several leased cars, and the booking records show how much the fleet is really used. People who drive every day, field sales for example, are still better served by an assigned car.

To weigh it against leasing, take a month of trip logs or fuel receipts and count how many of those cars are on the road at the same time in the busiest hour of a normal week. That number plus a margin is roughly the pool you would need. The costs to compare and how to run a short pilot are in our article on corporate car sharing.

When you choose software for it, look for an employee booking app, keyless access by phone, rules per role or department, monthly limits, mileage and fuel tracking, and reports. That is what our corporate car sharing software covers.

Launch your vehicle sharing app in just 15 days with CT Mobility!

No setup fees. Unlimited features.
Free trial period.